Village Bakery & Cafe

Village Bakery & Cafe

The friendly staff at the Village Bakery makes sure everyone on Put-in-Bay has fresh pastries and coffee to wake up to every morning. For over 20 years, Pauline and her staff has made the best pastries, cakes, and pies on the island. Coffee is ground every day and every piping hot cup is rich and strong. Perfect with a croissant or danish before heading out onto the boat or spending the day exploring the island.

Chocolate croissants, turnovers, and muffins are the baked fresh every day. Special occasion? The Village Bakery offers cakes and pies you can special order for your next big event. Besides pasties, they cook up hearty breakfast options and healthy lunches.

Village Bakery and Cafe is “Only Bakery of the Island.” Village Bakery and Cafe is your best and only choice if you need a wedding cake for your Put-in-Bay wedding. Pauline has been the owner for 21 years and knows her stuff. Village Bakery and Cafe will surely be here for many more years to come if Pauline and her employees continue to cook such scrumptious edibles on a yearly basis. Not having a wedding? Well, breakfast may still be enjoyed. Stroll by in the morning and give it a sniff. You’ll smell freshly grounded coffee and pastries such as butter croissants, apple turnovers, scones, and all sorts of muffins, and it will be hard to resist.

Village Bakery Breakfast and Lunch Highlights:
  • Griddle with Sausage, Egg, and Cheese on a Biscuit
  • Croissant with bacon, egg, and cheese
  • Smoked Ham Sandwich
  • Tuna and Chicken Salad
  • Village Salad with ham, pistachio, and craisins

Ice cream and sundaes are also on the menu. This really is the place for sweets! The Brownie Sundae is really out of this world! 

  • Village Salad – seasonal greens, tomato, ham, cheese, pistachios, and craisins
  • Tuna Salad – Starkist brand tuna, celery, sweet relish, onions, mayonnaise, and sour cream
  • Chicken Salad – roasted chicken, celery, sweet onion, sour cream, mayonnaise, and ranch
  • Vegetarian Delight – seasonal greens, tomato, cucumber pistachios, and craisins


Come in for the cinnamon rolls that Pauline makes on a Sunday. Get there early because there tends to not be enough to go around! All delicious yums are handmade, so custom ordering is not an issue and is actually encouraged. Are you hosting your own event? You’re not going to believe this, not only do Village Bakery and Cafe cater, but make it a professional habit.

Deli trays, lunch and dinner buffets, and large party trays: they’ll bring it right to your grateful guests. Village Bakery and Cafe would like to make your event special. Call to cater your next party!

Village Bakery Offerings:
  • Croissants and Chocolate Croissants
  • Fresh Homemade Muffins
  • Scones
  • Bundt Cakes
  • Pie (Lemon Meringue, Coconut Cream, Banana Cream, Fresh Fruit)
  • Specialty Cakes with fillings like Raspberry, Nutella, and White and Chocolate Icing

Besides their specialty cakes and pies, they have an extensive catering menu. Call them today in order to plan for an upcoming business meeting or party. They offer entrees like Glazed Ham, Meatloaf, and Chicken Paprikash along with sides like Macaroni and Cheese, Scalloped Potatoes, and Spaetzels.  Opt for a party tray for a large event or pastas for something a little different. Of course dessert trays are also available.

In terms of the cakes and pies, the skilled bakers can make anything your heart desires. German Chocolate Cake, cheesecakes, and even Wedding Cakes are all available. Put-in-Bay is a lovely place to get married and Village Bakery the perfect place to make a cake for your special day.


104 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, USA