Group Catering at Put-in-Bay: Feed Your Crew Without the Stress
Planning a getaway with a big group? Whether it’s a family reunion, bachelor party, corporate retreat, or wedding weekend, Put-in-Bay delivers more than stunning lake views and island fun—it also makes feeding a crowd effortless and enjoyable. You’ve already made the smart choice by booking your stay at the Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condos or Island Club Rentals—both ideal for large groups. Now it’s time to think about food. But don’t worry—you won’t be stuck in the kitchen. Put-in-Bay event catering offers a diverse range of catering options tailored to satisfy every palate and fit every occasion. From casual subs to full-scale wedding banquets, island vendors are ready to serve.
Why Plan Ahead for Catering?
Put-in-Bay is one of Ohio’s most popular seasonal destinations, especially in peak summer months. Planning your catering well in advance ensures your group’s needs are met without last-minute scrambling. Once you’ve nailed down your accommodations, securing your food plan is the next best step.
You’ll free up time, eliminate meal planning stress, and ensure everyone—yourself included—gets to enjoy the fun.
Perfect for Every Type of Event
Put-in-Bay’s caterers have experience feeding crowds of all kinds. Here’s just a sampling of the types of events they can support:
- 👶 Baby Showers & 🍼 Gender Reveals
- 💍 Bridal Showers & 💒 Wedding Receptions
- 🥂 Bachelor & Bachelorette Parties
- 👔 Corporate Outings & 💼 Networking Events
- 🏕️ Fishing Trips & ⛺ Camping Groups
- 🚌 School Field Trips
- 🧘♀️ Wellness Retreats
- 🎉 Birthday Parties, Anniversaries & Tailgates
No matter the occasion, there’s a Put-in-Bay catering option that’s perfect for your event.
Featured Catering Services on the Island
Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille
A Put-in-Bay icon, Mr. Ed’s is the ultimate group-friendly venue.
What Makes It Great:
- Can cater parties up to 200 people
- Offers private event space (including their 2nd-story deck!)
- Known for crowd-pleasing food like burgers, wings, wraps & seafood
- Casual pub atmosphere, ideal for lively groups
Perfect for: Bachelor parties, casual wedding receptions, reunions, and birthday bashes.
The Village Bakery & Cafe
This is more than a bakery—it’s a versatile caterer prepared for high-volume orders.
They Offer:
- Custom wedding cakes & pastries
- Breakfast platters, deli trays, entrees & desserts
- Friendly service & the island’s only full-service bakery
Perfect for: Weddings, bridal showers, brunches, and intimate celebrations.
Subway
Sometimes simple is best—Subway at Put-in-Bay is ready to help you keep things delicious and low-key.
Why It Works:
- Offers classic party subs and platters
- Consistent quality you can count on
- Great for fast, no-fuss meals between island adventures
Perfect for: Field trips, beach days, tailgates, and casual group meals.
The Crew’s Nest Catering
For upscale events, this is your go-to. The Crew’s Nest offers full banquet capabilities and elegant spaces for memorable island events.
What They Provide:
- Full catering for 2 to 400+ guests
- Flexible event spaces (clubhouse dining, lakeview patio, private lawn)
- Wedding receptions, rehearsal dinners, cocktail parties, and more
- Breakfast and brunch options are a must-try!
Perfect for: Weddings, corporate galas, milestone anniversaries, and high-end private events.
Bonus: Even More Catering Options on the Island
Many Put-in-Bay restaurants also offer custom group catering, even if they’re not widely advertised. From pizza places to steakhouses, it’s worth calling your favorite island spot and asking what they can do for your group.
Tip: Visit our Eat & Drink directory to explore a full list of restaurants and contact info.
Don’t Forget: Delivery, Pickup & On-Site Setups
Most catering vendors offer flexible options:
- 🍱 Delivered right to your condo or vacation rental
- 🍽️ Set up on-site at venues and pavilions
- 🧊 Coolers and warmers available for large outdoor events
- 🥗 Buffet-style or individual boxed meals available
You can even combine different vendors for different days: one for a welcome BBQ, another for a wedding reception, and something casual for departure day!
Make Memories, Not Menus
With so much to do and explore on Put-in-Bay, you deserve to enjoy every moment—not stress over meals. Let the island’s trusted catering services handle the food so you can focus on creating unforgettable experiences with your group.
📞 Ready to Book?
Reach out to caterers today, secure your group meals, and cross one more thing off your island getaway checklist. You’ll be glad you did!
Need help finding contact info or planning a multi-day catering schedule? I can create a custom itinerary with suggested dining themes and vendors—just let me know.
See you at the bay! 🙂