Put-in-Bay Bars and Restaurants

Put-in-Bay Restaurants: What You Need to Know

Put-in-Bay Restaurants

Here’s what we know, Put in Bay bars and restaurants will not disappoint!  Stop by The Keys where their fish tacos come highly recommended and reasonably priced. In the back of Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille you’ll find Cameo Pizza has a delicious meatball sub and pizza of course!

And the best part? All this great food is just a stroll from the Jet Express or a short golf cart ride away. No driving necessary! This means you can get an unbeatable lunch and be back at the pool or beach in no time flat. On bad-weather days, call a Put-in-Bay Taxi to get you there and stay warm and dry.

If you are looking for a little more than just a meal, many establishments serve outstanding food during the day, then turn into entertainment hotspots by night. From comedians to nationally known musical acts, you are sure to find excitement and variety your group will remember for a lifetime. Make sure to check out the island’s tallest structure Perry’s Monument on your next visit from Cleveland!

Put-in-Bay Island Restaurants Overview

With so many great dining options on the island, many of which offer a genuine beach vibe or an unbeatable view of the water, you will soon forget you are on an island off the coast of Ohio and start to believe you are visiting a Caribbean tiki bar. Put-in-Bay dining has so much to offer, and you are about to find out why!

Let’s take a journey through many of the best restaurants on Put-in-Bay.  Starting the journey, the outdoor seating is perfect at The Old Forge for a crepe and mimosa to begin the day. This creperie is a must with every visit to the island. Heading north towards downtown Put-in-Bay, a quick beer at the Put-In-Bay Brewery and Distillery on Catawba Ave really hits the spot.  It’s tempting to stop by Hooligans Irish Pub for some Lobster Bisque, but the mothership The Boardwalk is dead ahead. Stop Rita’s Cantina for nachos or Little Galley for a burger or hot dog while you are there. Walking past Mojito Bay, the sounds of live entertainment are in the air and the island gets ready good times and fun vibes!

Before reaching Bayview Ave, a Walleye Bites appetizer at Mossbacks is a delight.  Watching people in DeRivera Park and the Put-In-Bay Harbor is excellent from this eatery.  Next, a Brandy Alexander at Topsy Turvey is delightful.  The Cuban Sandwich here is excellent too!  However, a meal at The Boardwalk restaurant is the lunch plan in this culinary journey.  The Famous Lobster Bisque, freshest Lake Erie Perch and Alaskan King Crab are a must!  With lunch finished, a leisurely stroll on the docks is wonderful.

The Put-In-Bay Restaurant Journey Continues!

On to the Boathouse Bar for a quick margarita.  Diners can enjoy the outdoor seating and soak in the downtown Put-In-Bay nightlife scene.  The Village Bakery can be seen from the Delaware Ave patio where the freshest pastries are made each morning. You will also notice the Put-in-Bay Candy Bar across the street has delicious ice cream if you are feeling desert!

An excellent choice for a quick lunch is the Chicken Patio.  They are located outside the famous Roundhouse Bar on the corner of Loraine and Delaware Ave.  Also outside is Pasquale’s Café.  Here, a great breakfast, Italian classics and tasty pizza are the menu’s top sellers. Look for ice cream? Then Dairy Isle is the place to go.

The trip around town is nearly complete.  Just enough time for an icy cold beer at the Frosty Bar or snack from Mama Maria’s. Lastly, for the late night munchies, a burrito from The Reel Bar comes in clutch.

Outside the downtown area, there are some great Put-In-Bay Restaurants.  The Goat Soup and Whiskey is known for their Lake Erie Perch Tacos and soups made from scratch.  Joe’s Bar now features an expanded menu with great lunch specials daily.  No matter the choice, they serve tasty entrees and have fun drink options for all guests!

One of the most unique things about the Lake Erie Islands or “Key West of the North”, is that there are only local food options. The only chain restaurant is one Subway in the lobby of the Commodore Resort.

The newest place to eat is Swipe Right Pizza. The recently opened Put-in-Bay Pizza company opened the summer of 2020. Located at Joe’s Bar, the pizza is well worth a try! You can even take it to go and have a pizza picnic at the South Bass Island State Park.

We know, we know. This list makes it nearly impossible to choose just one or two Put-in-Bay restaurants during a short stay. Everything is so good! Not to mention all the other things to do in Put in Bay! May we suggest extending your stay at a Put in Bay resort, hotel, condo, or rental? Or visiting again soon? Book your next stay today!

Here are some of our most asked questions about Put-in-Bay restaurants

How many bars are in Put-in-Bay Ohio?

There are around 25 different bars at the Bay! They encompass everything from watering holes to swim-up bars, country saloons to sandy tropical-themed bars, and everything in-between! And many are within walking distance of each other in the famous downtown Put-in-Bay area. This includes Fishbowl and Tippers! Also check out Heinemans Winery and Put-in-Bay Winery for the best local wine on the island.

Can you make reservations for Put-in-Bay Restaurants?

The Goat Soup and Whiskey and Upper Deck take reservations for large parties! Grab an authentic German beer and enjoy it in the Biergarten. Most of the other Put-in-Bay’s restaurants do not take reservations. They are first come-first serve, and many do get very busy on weekend evenings so we advise that you plan ahead!

Where can I get seafood on Put-in-Bay?

There are many options on Put-in-Bay but the top 5 seafood restaurants according to guest reviews are The Boardwalk, The Keys, The Upper Deck, The Boathouse Bar & Grille, and Mossbacks.

Where can I see live entertainment at Put-in-Bay?

There are so many bars and restaurants that offer live entertainment! Some of the best places to enjoy local entertainment are Mr. Ed’s, the Roundhouse Bar, and The Boathouse Bar & Grille.

What are the best Put-in-Bay restaurants?

According to TripAdvisor reviews, The top ten restaurants on the island are as followed The Forge, Goat, Soup and Whiskey, Pasquales Cafe, Topsy Turvey’s, Hooligans, The Keys, Reel Bar, Upper Deck Restaurant, Mossbacks, and The Boardwalk.