Superb Put-in-Bay Restaurants

Craving a scrumptious cheeseburger? A juicy steak in a five-star setting? Some of the best chocolate the world has to offer? While our island is small, it is packed with diverse, delectable and downright delicious dining options your entire group will enjoy. And don’t forget the legendary Put-in-Bay bars that have made the island nightlife so famous!

Here, we have done all the work for you, collecting details about the best Put-in-Bay restaurants and bars, including their locations and contact information. That way, all you have to do is scroll down this page and make a decision about what you want to eat during your island vacation—although that may be easier said than done!

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille
, , , ,

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille is go-to spot for food and fun in Put-in-Bay. With a mouthwatering menu, full bar, and three entertainment venues, Mr. Ed’s slings the best in summertime fun. The daylight hours at Mr. Ed’s means patio seating by the lake, incredible food, and plenty of screen indoors to show all your favorite teams. They are known for their prized Chicken Chunks, succulent bites of poultry decked out in sauces like teriyaki, honey mustard, and hot garlic parmesan.   The extensive menu also includes perch sandwiches, insane burgers like the Hangover Burger and different types of Mac...

more information
The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s
,

The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s

As the most exclusive nightclub located in the heart of downtown, The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s is the best place to dance the night away on Put-in-Bay. The Green Room features beautiful views of Lake Erie, a 360 degree bar, and the best DJ’s in the region. The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s Details The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s is open Thursday – Sunday from 10pm – 2am. Each night features a DJ spinning the hottest tracks all night long. The club itself is located right above Mr. Ed’s on Delaware Avenue. Take a break from dancing and...

more information
Subway
, , ,

Subway

Subway on Put-in-Bay makes it easy to fuel up on delicious, fresh, and healthy food. Conveniently located with fast service and affordable eats, enjoy a sub anytime of day and then get back to summertime fun on Put-in-Bay. The signature scent of the fresh made bread greets visitors in the lobby of the Commodore Hotel. Located right on Delaware Ave, the Commodore is minutes from the Refuge Harbor and Perry Park. This is the perfect location to refuel. Subway offers an extensive variety of signature subs, healthy eats, and catering options. Some of their classics include Roast Beef and the...

more information
MIST Pool Bar
,

MIST Pool Bar

The hottest pool bar on Put-in-Bay, MIST Pool bar includes all the luxuries of a resort pool with the excitement of a high-end nightclub. This 21+ spot is definitely one of the most exclusive spots on the whole island. MIST Pool Bar Details Located at the Commodore Resort, MIST is open to both hotel guests and visitors. The best regional DJ’s spin here all weekend long as two waterfalls cascade into the pool and revelers have the time of their lives. The pool is crystal clean with 2000 square feet of climate controlled perfection. It is regularly cleaned with a...

more information
Put-in-Bay Winery Dining
,

Put-in-Bay Winery Dining

Located at the beautiful Doller House Estate on the banks of Lake Erie, Put-in-Bay Winery provides a sophisticated, peaceful setting perfect for enjoying a glass of delicious wine. Tours of the site are given on a daily basis and this Italianate beauty makes an ideal spot to host your next special event. Put-in-Bay Winery Details Founded in 2009, Put-in-Bay Winery is dedicated to educating their visitors about the history of winemaking with their winery exhibitions in their Museum of Island life and tours of the estate. There is also a positively charming wine garden overlooking the lake and a gift...

more information
DJ’s Ice Cream

DJ’s Ice Cream

Summertime on Put-in-Bay means sun, fun, and plenty of ice cream. DJ’s Ice Cream more than delivers on everyone’s favorite creamy confection. Serving up some of the best ice cream of the island, this charming shop is located right in the heart of downtown just a short walk from the Jet Express Ferry. DJ’s Ice Cream Details The friendly staff serves up their 16 ice cream flavors with a smile. Each flavor is delicious in its own way. Classic favorites like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry satisfy everyone while the more creative flavors like Superman and Mint Chocolate Chip surprise and...

more information
Dairy Isle

Dairy Isle
Top Pick

Greeting visitors disembarking from the Jet Express Terminal, Dairy Isle is located right on Bayview Avenue. With its friendly yellow umbrellas on the patio and delicious offerings inside, Dairy Isle makes a perfect first stop on Put-in-Bay. Dairy Isle Details Located right next to DeRivera Park and close to all the best downtown attractions, a trip to Dairy Isle is pretty much a given on your day out on the town. Enjoy the sight of Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial, the banks of Lake Erie, and the citizens of Put-in-Bay walking by while you enjoy your tasty treats. You...

more information
The Fish Bowl

The Fish Bowl

A favorite hangout amongst both visitors locals on Put-in-Bay, the Fish Bowl delivers a comfortable, festive environment with a great menu and delicious drinks. This recently renovated building is located on Catawba in the heart of downtown. The expansive front windows provide great views of all the summer parading going by. The Fish Bowl Details Both the Fish Bowl and Mossbacks are located in the Valentine Doller building, a Victorian building with the words V. Doller carved on the front. This building once belonged to Valentine Doller who served as the island first postmaster as well as its mayor. The...

more information
Mama Maria’s Pizza

Mama Maria’s Pizza

Mama Maria’s Pizza serves up piping hot, cheese covered pizza all summer long. Opened after midnight, it is perfect for a late night snack after barhopping in downtown Put-in-Bay. Mama Maria’s Menu Highlights Fresh ingredients, plenty of cheese and sauce, delicious crust, and fun toppings are the recipe for a perfect slice. Mama Maria’s makes sure there is something for everyone with their eclectic menu. They also make humongous meatball subs. All-beef meatballs are covered in heaping portions of sauce and cheese on a fresh roll. They also offer wraps. They also soft drinks, Red Bull, and other assorted drinks....

more information

Put-in-Bay Restaurants: What You Need to Know

Here’s what we know, Put-in-Bay bars and restaurants will not disappoint! From scrumptious seafood and fine dining to chicken wings and bisque and chowder you can’t resist, the island has become a Mecca for good food and a good time. And the best part? All this flavorful food is just a short golf cart ride away. No driving necessary! Which means you can get an unbeatable lunch and be back at the pool or beach in no time flat.

If you are looking for a little more than just a meal, many establishments serve outstanding food during the day, then turn into entertainment hotspots by night. From comedians to nationally known musical acts, you are sure to find excitement and variety your group will remember for a lifetime.

Island Eats and Treats

With so many dining options, many of which offer a genuine beach vibe or an unbeatable view of the water, you will soon forget you are on an island off the coast of Ohio and start to believe you are visiting the Caribbean. Put-in-Bay dining has so much to offer, and you are about to find out why!

We know, we know. This list makes it nearly impossible to choose just one or two Put-in-Bay restaurants during a short stay. Everything is so good! May we suggest extending your stay? Or visiting again soon? Book your next stay today!