If there’s one food that is universally loved, easy, fast, fun and great for any situation, it’s pizza. There are some sensational pizza options at Put-in-Bay to fill the craving for that cheesy, saucy goodness. Some deliver, some are open as late as 3 AM for the bar crowd, all of them hit the spot when you need an ‘slice’ of the island life!

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille
, , , ,

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille

Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille is go-to spot for food and fun in Put-in-Bay. With a mouthwatering menu, full bar, and three entertainment venues, Mr. Ed’s slings the best in summertime fun. The daylight hours at Mr. Ed’s means patio seating by the lake, incredible food, and plenty of screen indoors to show all your favorite teams. A new feature to the Put in Bay restaurants, Mr. Ed’s has recently added Put-in-Bay’s famous Cameo Pizza to their roster. Enjoy all the delicious pizza, bosco stix, and Chicken Wings decked out in sauces like teriyaki, honey mustard, and hot garlic parmesan....

more information
Mama Maria’s Pizza

Mama Maria’s Pizza

Mama Maria’s Pizza serves up piping hot, cheese covered pizza all summer long. Opened after midnight, it is perfect for a late night snack after barhopping in downtown Put-in-Bay. Mama Maria’s Menu Highlights Fresh ingredients, plenty of cheese and sauce, delicious crust, and fun toppings are the recipe for a perfect slice. Mama Maria’s makes sure there is something for everyone with their eclectic menu. They also make humongous meatball subs. All-beef meatballs are covered in heaping portions of sauce and cheese on a fresh roll. They also offer wraps. They also soft drinks, Red Bull, and other assorted drinks....

more information
Put-in-Bay Brewery and Distillery
, ,

Put-in-Bay Brewery and Distillery

The Put-in-Bay Brewery and Distillery opened in 1996 and is Put-in-Bay’s first brewery. The building itself is over 100 years old. First owned by Valentine Doller, one the of the islands most known residents, Doller served as the third mayor of the island. Over time, it functioned as a grocery store, gas station, and even fire station. Now, unlike other Put in Bay bars it brews locally made craft beer to the delight of island visitors. It features a rotating menu all summer long, depending on the brew schedule. They specialize in stouts and wheat beers, crafting a variety of...

more information
Frosty Bar
, ,

Frosty Bar

The Frosty Bar has been a Put-in-Bay institution for over 60 years.There are a lot of Put in Bay bars, but Frosty is known for serving up ice cold beers in their signature frosty mugs. This bar is a favorite of everyone, from boaters, to day trippers, vacationers, and Island natives. Frosty is a classic dive bar with a Put-in-Bay twist. With extra delicious food served up alongside live music, pool tables, and the game on TV, it is the perfect spot to celebrate summer on Put-in-Bay. Big Man’s Burrito Stand is located at the rear of the property if you crave...

more information
Cameo Pizza
,

Cameo Pizza

Put in Bay restaurants vary from place to place, but many are famous for grilling, cookouts and picnics, but sometimes you just want a slice of pizza! If that’s the case head on over to Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille. Inside you’ll find Cameo Pizza. Their fast service and fresh ingredients combine to make this the marquee pizza destination on the island! But it’s not just pizza, they also have salads, subs sandwiches and more. Cameo Pizza’s new location is in Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille. You’ll find counter ordering inside, and you can eat in Mr. Ed’s! Mr. Ed’s...

more information