Discover the best fine dining restaurants in Put-in-Bay Ohio. These elegant venues offer their guest exquisite dining with amazing atmosphere, fine wines and delicious chef inspired menus. Put-in-Bay Fine Dining at its best!

Goat Soup & Whiskey
With an eclectic menu, fresh ingredients from on-site gardens, and casual fine dining, Goat Soup & Whiskey is Put-in-Bay dining at its best. This restaurant serves up delicious food in a peaceful, sophisticated setting. Their outdoor seating is beautiful and the setting tucked away from the hustle and bustle of downtown Put in Bay attractions. The chefs at Goat Soup & Whiskey take pride in everything they make. There’s no better indication of that than the three gardens on the premise. They use fresh herbs and vegetables in their appetizers, entrees, and cocktails. They also source berry’s from nearby Bergman’s...More Information
Upper Deck Restaurant
One of the most spectacular spots in all of Put-in-Bay, the Upper Deck of the Boardwalk Restaurant, offers fine dining with amazing lake views. Make sure to try the lobster bisque. It is the best in the region and there is a lot of Put in Bay restaurants to compete with! The Upper Deck serves fresh seafood like Alaskan King Crab, tasty burgers, and pasta alongside friendly, accommodating service. It features an extensive martini and margarita menu so sit back and enjoy your time on Put-in-Bay. The Boardwalk The main stopping put on Put-in-Bay, The Boardwalk sits right on Lake Erie,...More Information
White linens and fine dining are something you won’t find much of at Put-in-Bay Ohio. Thanks to the island’s history as a favorite casual tropical-style destination for boaters. For decades, local restaurants have been serving the finest cuts of meat, the freshest Walleye of the day and the great produce and herbs grown right on the island. Today, our “fine dining” restaurants continue in this tradition, offering unmatched service for a special night out, but clothing as resort casual. Eating a delicious steak in flip flops? Yes, you can do that at Put-in-Bay Fine Dining!