The Old Forge Cafe and Creperie sets itself apart from most Put in Bay restaurants. They specialize in light, fluffy crepes full of delicious fillings. Open for breakfast, lunch and dinner, The Old Forge is one of the great things to do in Put in Bay with their excellent menu. Croissants sandwiches, and egg dishes round out their impressive menu. They use high quality and fresh ingredients to make their incredible savory and sweet crepes.
The Old Forge Menu
Crepes are commonly eaten with your hands, like the classic lemon and sugar crepes available on the streets of Paris. At Old Forge, they make crepes stuffed with so much goodness, you need a knife and fork to eat them. Try their Fancy Pants crepe with smoked salmon, cheese, arugula, and a poached egg. Or you can opt for the Crazy Sam with bacon, chicken, pico de gallo, and topped with a sriracha cream. You can add avocado to any crepe you like. Perhaps not the Raspberry Cheesecake crepe. That has all the flavor you need with a dollop of whipped cream on top.
The Old Forge features a full bar so make sure to order a mimosa for breakfast. The skilled bartenders can concoct any cocktail your heart desire’s and there’s a great list of wine and beer. Other options include Eggs Benedict with prosciutto and a side of potatoes, breakfast burritos, and rich, juicy sliders. Healthier options like the Kale Salad with Goat Cheese are also available for those who prefer a lighter dish.
The Old Forge is tucked away on a side street in downtown Put-in-Bay. The ambience with low-key and casual with expert service. The patio is perfect for sunny mornings and warm summer nights. Close proximity to the downtown hotels like the Commodore Resort Hotel and Victory Station Hotel makes it easy to visit anytime.The Commodore is the only Put in Bay resort, so it offers a unique experience for visitors who decide to stay there. Neighbors include some of the favorite bars in Put in Bay like Hooligans and the Put-in-Bay Brewery and Distillery.