Almost everything at Put-in-Bay is casual. Flip-flops and tank tops might as well be the island uniform. However, there are some Put-in-Bay restaurants where you won’t feel out of place in jeans and a button-down. Places with menus that aren’t laminated. Where you can sit down with friends and family and be taken care of for an hour or two. Nothing to worry about but a enjoying a great Put-in-Bay meal with people you care about. These are those spots.
Casual Cuisine, Restaurants, Pizza, Featured Restaurants, Bars & Pubs
🎸 Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille: Where Put-in-Bay’s Pulse Lives There’s a reason Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille is more than just a restaurant—it’s a Put-in-Bay institution. Nestled right in the heart of downtown, across from the iconic Derivera Park, this high-energy hotspot brings together the best of island life, lake views, live entertainment, and lip-smacking eats. Whether you’re grabbing lunch with the family or throwing down drinks with your crew until the early hours, Mr. Ed’s is the place where memories are made. A Day at Mr. Ed’s Imagine this: It’s noon on a sunny summer day. You’ve...More Information
Casual Cuisine, Restaurants, Featured Restaurants, Bars & Pubs
Classic bar food, outdoor games, and a fun, friendly vibe is on deck at Joe’s Bar & Restaurant. This gastropub serves up some of the most delectable bar foods anywhere on the island. A little tucked away from downtown Put-in-Bay, Joe’s is the self-proclaimed “Best Dive Bar on the Planet.” Order a Sloppy Joe’s Dip or Artichoke Asiago Dip and take a seat in their expansive outdoor patio. There are plenty of things to do in Put in Bay, especially at Joe’s Bar, like playing over-sized Jenga and Corn Hole. Joe’s is the perfect place to spend summers in Put-in-Bay,...More Information
Casual Cuisine, Restaurants, Deli & To Go, Featured Restaurants
Subway on Put-in-Bay, Ohio makes it easy to fuel up on delicious, fresh, and healthy food. Conveniently located with fast service and affordable eats, enjoy a sub any time of day and then get back to summertime fun on Put-in-Bay. The signature scent of the freshly made bread greets visitors in the lobby of the Commodore Hotel. Located right on Delaware Ave, the Commodore is minutes from the Refuge Harbor and Perry Park. This is the perfect location to refuel on South Bass Island. Conveniently located by Delaware Ave and Catawba Ave. You can take your fresh sub and enjoy a...More Information
Restaurants, Wineries, Distilleries, & Microbreweries
The Put-in-Bay Winery follows the grape from when it is first planted in the rich soil, through its journey of becoming bottled wine, till it eventually becomes the tasteful talk in the wine tasting room or the bottled souvenir wine to be brought home and enjoyed with friends and family. Visitors to the winery are able to sample a variety of wines that are grown and made around the island. Guests are able to enjoy a glass of wine while outside in the garden or on the front porch of the Doller House Estate with its lakeside views of the...More Information
Restaurants, Casual Cuisine, Coffee & Breakfast
The Old Forge Cafe and Creperie set itself apart from the other Put in Bay, Ohio restaurants. They specialize in light, fluffy crepes full of delicious fillings. Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, The Old Forge is one of the great things to do in Put in Bay with its excellent menu. Croissant sandwiches and egg dishes round out their impressive dining options. They use high quality and fresh ingredients to make their incredible savory and sweet crepes. Check out their location on Delaware Ave. The Old Forge Menu Crepes are commonly eaten with your hands, like the classic lemon...More Information
While Put-in-Bay has long been known for its party and music scene, our culinary scene is garnering the attention of its own. Many bloggers are now writing about the unique dining opportunities on South Bass Island. You can find Put-in-Bay’s authentic flavors all over town showing the German, Nordic, and European influences of early settlers. Put-in-Bay restaurants have their own personality and welcome all walks of life.