Gifts

A charming complex of stores, The Shops at Compass Pointe features a lovely selection of fine gifts, apparel, even knife sharpening! A short walk from downtown Put-in-Bay, Compass Pointe offers a pleasant shopping experience in a beautiful setting. The Shops at Compass Pointe Dock 421 The Little Store Happy Holidays Island Hardware Home Port Dock 421 is a favorite of visitors and locals alike with a great selection of casual wear for both men and women. Home Port offers nautically-inspired gifts and decor while the Little Store provides a very big jewelry selection. Stock up on plenty of Ohio and...

Stop by The Lobster Trap next time you are dining at the Boardwalk Restaurant. Located right on the banks of Lake Erie, the Boardwalk contains a diverse offering of restaurants and bars, from casual to fine dining. The Lobster Trap carries nautically-themed gifts, from pillows to figurines, perfect for all the fisherman and women that flock to Put-in-Bay. Their quirky t-shirts and sweatshirts show off the Boardwalk name. Available in a range of bright colors and styles, there is something to cater to everyone’s taste. Visitors can purchase their award-winning Bloody Mary mix to make at home. Just add vodka...

The Great Lakes Tobacconist, also known as Richard Warren, is a Put-in-Bay Legend. Celebrated far and wide for his diverse talents he grows a giant pumpkin every year just for Oktoberfest. He also dons a pirate costume for Pyratefest. And perhaps his most specialized talent is his Historic Put-in-Bay Cigars. Over the last few years, Richard has put together a collection of five different cigars, all inspired by Put-in-Bay. Personally blended by Richard, these babies are rolled by Kilner Boutique Factory in Tamboril, Dominican Republic. The Great Lakes Tobacconist Cigars Island Airlines Miller Ferry Niagara Monument Heineman Winery Each cigar...

Together the Crystal Cave and Heineman Winery make for a delightful afternoon. Located about a mile from downtown Put-in-Bay, the Crystal Cave Gift Shops sells wine from Heineman’s as well as souvenirs, geodes, crystals, and gems. Some even come directly from the cave. Heineman’s Winery Heineman’s Winery has been producing locally made wine since 1888. Founded by German immigrant Gustav Heineman, this winery takes advantage of the long growing season on the island due to the tempering effect of Lake Erie. Ideal soil conditions help produce superior grapes. After Prohibition wiped out most of the 17 wineries on Put-in-Bay in...

The Bucket Shop is a one-stop-shop of fans of the world-renowned Round House Bar. Celebrate your time at the Round House and Put-in-Bay by scooping up some swag at The Bucket Shop. The Bucket Shop Offerings Fun items include hoodies, t-shirts, polo shirts, earrings, and blankets. Show your love for the Round House by donning a pair of red bucket earrings. There are dog leashes, drink containers, even a wine barrel! They specialize in fun and silly socks in every color of stripes. Baseball hats come in a range of styles, some even pre-distressed! Bring home a gift for those...

Bay View Gifts offers a wonderful selection of perfectly curated apparel and gifts. Chosen with care by the proprietors, Bay View Gifts makes a perfect stopping off point while you stroll through Put-in-Bay. Bay View Gifts Location Located on Bayview Avenue a little removed from downtown, Bay View Gifts will delight you with its high-quality items. Buy a gift for someone on the mainland or a souvenir to remind you of your time on Put-in-Bay. Bay View Gifts sits right on the shores of Lake Erie. The Put-in-Bay Yacht Club is right up with street. Members of the club enjoy...

If you come to the island by way of the Miller Ferry, the first place you’re going to encounter is Dockside Gifts. And if you leave the island by way of the Miller Ferry, Dockside Gifts is going to be your last chance to grab a few souvenirs. So talk about location! Dockside Gifts doesn’t disappoint either, with a bunch of awesome Put-in-Bay memorabilia to check out. They can also get you an ice-cold soda or a piping hot coffee if you just got off the ferry and need a drink! Where to find Dockside Gifts Dockside Gifts is at...

Local Color might be the most unique shop at Put-in-Bay. That’s one of the best things about vacation shopping, those small shops that have so much more than you’d expect. Put-in-Bay is renowned for this, so many of their shops are wild and unique. But Local Color may take the cake. This tiny shop, unmissable with its Salmon colored paint job, is loaded with awesome Put-in-Bay memorabilia. You’ll find the expected glassware and t-shirts that you’d find at any souvenir shop, but that’s just the start. They also stock artwork from the island’s artists, jewelry handmade at Put-in-Bay, awesome stuffed...

The Wharfside is the place for all you need for a day out on the lake. They have bait, tackle, and fishing accessories, as well as the snacks and beverages you’ll need to fill your cooler up with while you’re out on the water. Forgot your cooler? No worries, they’ve got that too! If you plan to fish, you’ll need an Ohio Fishing License. Guess where you can get one of those? That’s right, the Wharfside. Cigarettes, party supplies and more, it’s all here. The Wharfside and Topsy Turvey The Wharfside is in downtown near where the Put in Bay...