Downtown Dave Profiles Island Music Acts
So last week’s post was about what it is like to live on an island. This week is going to be a short write up about the bands that I watch on Put in Bay. I do not have the time to see every band or solo performer but I will do my best to highlight some of the best that I have seen. But please go and check out some of the solo artists and maybe some of the others that I have not mentioned. They are all pros and very good.
I will list the band or solo artists along with where you can see them play and my personal comments of each performer.
We’ll get into it right after the music schedule!
Put-in-Bay Live Music Schedule 8/7-8/16
Mr. Ed’s
Thurs Aug 13th Until Rust 1:30 Ronnie Szucs 5:30 Fun Buckets 9:30
Friday Aug 14th Jack Surtman 1:30 Until Rust 5:30 Matt Whataguy Band 9:30
Sat Aug 15th Until Rust 1:30 Casper 5:30 Matt Whataguy Band 9:30
Sun Aug 16th Until Rust 2:00 Casper 6:30 DJ ADUBB 11:00
Mon Aug 17th Reckless Highway Duo 3:00 Fun Buckets 9:00
Tues Aug 18th Reckless Highway Duo 3:00 Fun Buckets 9:00
Weds Aug 19th Reckless Highway Duo 3:00 Fun Buckets 9:00
Thurs Aug 20th Travis Faber 1:30 Hunter Hoop 5:30 Fun Buckets 9:00
Friday Aug 21st Sully 1:30 Hunter Hoop 5:30 Our Short Years 9:30
Sat Aug 22nd Nick Ammons 1:30 Casper 5:30 Our Short Years 9:30
Sun Aug 23rd Jeff Harris 2:00 Casper 6:30 DJ ADUBB 11:00
Mon Aug 24th Jeff Harris 3:00 Shot 30 9:00
Round House Bar
Thurs Aug 13th Sellouts 2:00 Emilys Toybox 8:30
Friday Aug 14th Mad Dog 2:00 Emilys Toybox 8:30
Sat Aug 15th Mad Dog 2:00 Paul Franks 6:30 Emilys Toybox 9:30
Sun Aug 16th Screaming Heathens Duo 2:00 Rusty Snow 8:30
Mon Aug 17th Jerry Sprague 2:00 Rusty Snow 8:30
Tues Aug 18th Jerry Sprague 2:00 Rusty Snow 8:30
Weds Aug 19th Paradise Island 2:00 Rusty Snow 8:30
Thurs Aug 20th Paradise Island 2:00 Y2Kids 8:30
Friday Aug 21st Amelia Airharts 2:00 Y2Kids 8:30
Sat Aug 22nd Amelia Airharts 2:00 Paul Franks 6:30 Y2Kids 9:30
Sun Aug 23rd Michelle and Ryan Trio 2:00 and 8:30
Mon Aug 24th Dustin Kines Duo 2:00 and 8:30
Beer Barrel
Thurs Aug 13th Justin Marchand 2:00 Kyle Smithers 6:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Friday Aug 14th Justin Marchand 2:00 Jason Saitta 6:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Sat Aug 15th Justin Marchand 2:00 Jason Saitta 6:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Sun Aug 16th Justin Marchand 2:00 Jason Saitta 6:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Mon Aug 17th Jason Saitta 3:00 Tobi Lee 7:30 The Fulcos 9:30
Tues Aug 18th Jason Saitta 3:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Weds Aug 19th Kyle Smithers 2:00 Tobi Lee 6:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Thurs Aug 20th Kyle Smithers 2:00 Tobi Lee 6:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Friday Aug 21st Kyle Smithers 2:00 Tobi Lee 6:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Sat Aug 22nd Kyle Smithers 2:00 Tobi Lee 6:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Sun Aug 23rd Kyle Smithers 2:00 Tobi Lee 6:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Mon Aug 24th Kyle Smithers 3:00 Tobi Lee 7:00 The Fulcos 9:30
Reel Bar
Friday Aug 14th Nick Brownell 2:00 Ray Fogg 7:00
Sat Aug 15th Nick Brownell 2:00 Ray Fogg 7:00
Sun Aug 16th Nick Brownell 2:00 Bob Gatewood 7:30
Friday Aug 21st Nick Brownell 2:00 Ray Fogg 7:00
Sat Aug 22nd Nick Brownell 2:00 Ray Fogg 7:00
Sun Aug 23rd Nick Brownell 2:00 Bob Gatewood 7:30
Fish Bowl
Thurs Aug 13th Pat Masalko 7:00
Friday Aug 14th Lucas Guy 3:00 Pat Masalko 7:00
Sat Aug 15th Pat Masalko 1:00 DJ Tritt 7:00
Weds Aug 19th KARAOKE 8:00
Thurs Aug 20th Pat Masalko 7:00
Friday Aug 21st Pat Masalko 4:00 DJ ADUBB 8:00
Sat Aug 22nd Pat Masalko 1:00 DJ Lano 7:00
Frostys
Thurs Aug 13th Rusty Bladen 8:00
Friday Aug 14th Rusty Bladen 8:00
Sat Aug 15th Pat Shepard 2:00 Rusty Bladen 8:00
Sun Aug 16th Josh and Jordan 2:00
Friday Aug 21st Next Chapter 8:00
Sat Aug 22nd Pat Shepard 2:00 Next Chapter 8:00
Sun Aug 23rd Maria Diem 2:00
Boathouse
Friday Aug 14th DJ ADUBB 9:00
Sat Aug 15th DJ ADUBB 9:00
Friday Aug 21st Alan Carl Band 9:00
Sat Aug 22nd Alan Carl Band 9:00
Mojito Bay
Friday Aug 14th Brad Moore 4:00 Fire on Fire 8:00
Sat Aug 15th Conner Flowers 12:00 Brad Moore 4:00 Fire on Fire
Sun Aug 16th Brad Moore 2:00 Tucker Munz
Mon Aug 17th Tucker Munz 8;00
Tues Aug 18th Tucker Munz 8;00
Weds Aug 19th Lee Gantt 8:00
Thurs Aug 20th Lee Gantt 8:00
Friday Aug 21st Sunset Duo 4:00 Imaginary Cookies 8:00
Sat Aug 22nd Jeff White 12:00 Sunset Duo 4:00 Imaginary Cookies 8:00
Sun Aug 23rd Sunset Duo 2:00 Jeff White 8:00
Mon Aug 24th Jeff White 7:00
Brewery
Friday Aug 14th Johnny Martens 3:00
Sat Aug 15th Galen Martin 2:00
Sun Aug 16th Rob Samay 2:00
Friday Aug 21st Guy Lucas 2:00
Sat Aug 22nd Guy Lucas 2:00
Sun Aug 23rd Todd Stephen 2:00
Also Karaoke every Friday and Saturday night
The Keys
Aug 11-13th Sunset Duo
Aug 14-15th Ben Beallas
Aug 16-17th Austen Hamilton
Aug 18-20th Renegade Lemonade
Aug 21-23rd Jimmy Jack
Aug 24th Steve Kennedy
All artists play 2 shows a day. One around lunch and the other show around dinner time
The Goat
Aug 15th Phil Yan Polka Band 1:00
2026 putinbayohio.com’s Best Places To Stay!
- Island Club Rentals (islandclub.com) – 216-898-9951
- Commodore Resort (commodoreresort.com) – 419-285-3101
- Bird’s Nest Resort (birdsnestresort.com) – 419-285-6119
- Put-in-Bay Condos (putinbaycondos.com) 216-898-1105
- Victory Station Hotel (putinbayvictorystation.com) 419-285-0120
My Thoughts For The Week
Casper I talked about him last year and my comments are still the same. He is one of the most unappreciated musicians on Put in Bay. He plays at Mr Eds solo and with the band Fun Buckets on Thursday nights. I do not think there is a song that he cannot do and do it well. Please check him out and make a request. you will be surprised.
Mike Mad Dog Adams He is an island Legend at the Roundhouse. He has been playing there for over 40 years. I probably see him 3 times a month just to watch the blowing of the conch shell at around 3:30 every show. You cannot leave his show without smiling or remembering a joke that you tell to your friends.
Paradise Island Another 40 year performer at the Roundhouse. There is a reason why because they pack the place every Wednesday. How many bands pack a place on a Wednesday afternoon. One of the few bands that do not play so loud that you cannot talk to the person that you are with. Plus lots of great dance music to dance to
Emilys Toy Box One of my favorites bands. They are from around the State College Pa. area. The lead singer is probably the most entertaining and engaging on the island with the crowd. When you see them, really listen to the lyrics. He loves to change the words to songs. I remember seeing them in Cleveland many years ago. They are a bit on the loud side but definitely worth seeing.
Kyle Smithers A few years ago I was walking by the Beer Barrel and heard a Pat Daily song. Well it was Kyle. I stayed for awhile and was impressed with some of the songs that he played. Now some of his songs are a little dirty but definitely worth having a few beers with on the Patio at the Beer Barrel.
Tobi Lee another Beer Barrel regular. I do now between her and Kyle they probably do over 100 shows combined this summer. Kyle usually first and Tobi second. Tobi is the lead singer of Mustang Sally. I really do not think she has a set list. She plays a lot of requests and she packs the patio at the Beer Barrel every weekend.
The Fulcos They are originally from NYC but now play out of Clearwater Florida. Also they do not have a set list. They do play some of the same songs every night but never in the same order. They play to what motivates the crowd. I just saw them play a song by Eric Carmen and the Raspberries from Cleveland the other day. They can play stuff from the 50s all the way to current stuff. They start at 9:30 and they do not take a break. I do not know of many bands that do that anymore. Most bands are play 1 1/2 hours 30 minute break the finish 1 1/2 hour set. Please see them before they outgrow Put in Bay.
Nick Brownell Originally from this area but plays in Key West a lot. He is a 1 man show and really puts his own spin on every show. Grab a burger at the Reel bar and enjoy his show.
Ray Fogg Plays at the Reel Bar most weekends. But also does a few select gigs at the Roundhouse when we turn the Whiskey light on and when we turn it off. Well I do not know how long he has been playing here but I know I saw him over 20 years ago in the upstairs of the Brewery. Most of his material is original and I know most of the words to his songs. Even though I have seen him many times and know his songs you will still find me there on some weekends and I always leave with a smile. He also has Cds of his original material.
Bob Gatewood Plays at the Reel Bar solo and with Calabash at the Roundhouse. Bob is now a good friend of mine. I wish I would have met him earlier in his career so I could have watched him play more. Calabash has now played at the Roundhouse for 40 years also. You have to be good if you keep getting asked back for that long. In his solo show he does some cool things that make it sound like he has a band behind him and also other vocals. He has lots of original songs that have even gotten on the radio. The last song that he does is always Friends of the Bay. It is the official song of Put in Bay.
Rusty Bladen plays at Frostys. I was a little skeptical when I saw him in person. I am thinking how can this guy be good. But to me he is your everyday musician and he is good. Polished and plays to his strengths. He has a great band that is fun to watch. You will not sit down when he is playing. You will probably dance or just sing along.
Pat Shepard also at Frostys. I have no idea how long he has played at Frostys but once again if you are not good and cannot hold a crowd they will not ask you back. He is both. Does some great Pat Daily songs alongs with others that make you sing along. I really think a Frostys Pizza a beer in a frosted mug and Pat Shepard on a Saturday afternoon go together.
So I did my best to make my personal comments on everybody playing at Put in Bay over the next few weeks that I have personally seen. I know that I have missed seeing many of the artists listed in this weeks music schedule but I only have so much time. I might try in future posts to comment on people that I have seen that I have not commented on so far. The artists that I commented on above are in no particular order of preference. If you are an artist that I have not seen please reach out to me and I will do my best to check out your show.
Please support live music. Some of the musicians do this for a living. Please tip them to show your appreciation.
putinbayohio.com Quick Picks
- Put-in-Bay Attractions
- Put-in-Bay Event Calendar For 2026
- The Best Put-in-Bay Bars and Dining
- How To Get To Put-in-Bay
